review · 2014 · en
El Sistema and the Manipulation of Music Education: Why Are We Still So in Thrall?
Baker G
Oxford University Press (book)
Evidencia · Alta
Síntesis
Critical book-length study by Geoff Baker challenging hagiographic accounts of El Sistema: documents authoritarian pedagogy, gender disparities, weak academic outcomes, and conflation of program intensity with social mobility claims.
Etapas
6-12, 12-18
Dominios
music, education, equity, latam
Tags
El-Sistema · critique · Geoff-Baker · Venezuela · hagiography · music-education-critical
Afirmaciones que citan esta fuente (1)
clm-el-sistema-mixed-evidence
El Sistema and Sistema-inspired programs in Latin America (Venezuela, Colombia, Chile) show consistent socioemotional and community-cohesion benefits, but academic-transfer evidence is weak and critical scholarship (Baker) documents authoritarian pedagogy and over-claiming; progr